The truth about vitamin D supplements

Vitamin D, also known as the sunshine vitamin, is often recommended as a supplement by governments worldwide. But do we really need these pills? Do they work, or could they potentially harm us? In this episode, ZOE's top scientists, Professor Tim Spector and Dr Federica Amati, shed light on the truth about vitamin D. Tim, a scientific co-founder of ZOE and a professor at King's College London, and Federica, head nutritionist at ZOE and author of 'Every Body Should Know This,' discuss the importance of vitamin D, how much is needed, where it can be found in food, and whether supplements are necessary. Make informed food choices by becoming a member at zoe.com - get 10% off with code PODCAST. Explore our new plant-based wholefood supplement, Daily 30+. Have feedback or a topic suggestion? Let us know. Access episode transcripts here.

Transcript

[00:00:00] Jonathan Wolf: Welcome to ZOE Science and Nutrition, where world-leading scientists explain how their research can improve your health.

Vitamin D, also known as the sunshine vitamin, plays a crucial role in our overall health, from bone health to cancer prevention. However, with reports of one billion people having low vitamin D levels and nearly half being dangerously deficient, questions arise about the necessity and safety of vitamin D supplements. In this episode, Professor Tim Spector and Dr Federica Amati, two of ZOE's top scientists, share their insights on vitamin D. Tim, a professor of epidemiology and scientific co-founder of ZOE, and Federica, head nutritionist at ZOE and author of 'Every Body Should Know This,' provide valuable information on vitamin D, its sources, and the myths surrounding its consumption. Let's dive in.

It is more similar to a steroid than a vitamin, and our reactions to it would be different if we called it a steroid instead. Despite being labeled as a vitamin for the past hundred years, it is actually a parahormone that plays a crucial role in various bodily functions, particularly immune health. Vitamin D is essential for immune reactions, inflammation, allergies, aging, and cancer, as well as bone health and growth. Unlike other vitamins that must be ingested, our bodies can synthesize vitamin D, primarily through sunlight exposure. Although it can also be obtained from food, sunlight is the most effective way to ensure an adequate intake of vitamin D. The recommended daily intake of vitamin D varies between countries, with the U.S. and U.K. having different guidelines based on blood levels and supplementation. Vitamin D deficiency can lead to diseases like rickets and osteomalacia, which were more prevalent in the past when vitamin D levels were lower. To be considered as having sufficient vitamin D, you need to have very high blood levels. However, determining the exact level is challenging because the measurement is done within the cells rather than directly from the blood. This push for higher levels has been influenced more by commercial interests rather than scientific evidence. Experts in vitamin D agree that there is no universal amount needed, as each individual has a unique genetic basis for their vitamin D levels. This makes it difficult to establish a standard level for everyone worldwide.

Deficiency in vitamin D can lead to significant changes in bone structure, especially in children, resulting in painful fractures that heal poorly. While severe deficiency leading to conditions like rickets is rare in the U.S. and Western Europe, reports suggest that a significant portion of the population may have insufficient levels of vitamin D. Symptoms of deficiency can include depression, fatigue, and various mental health issues. Higher levels of vitamin D are often associated with healthier individuals, but the confusion arises when trying to determine if increasing vitamin D levels will lead to overall better health. Tim Spector and Dr. Federica Amati both have differing views on the necessity of vitamin D supplementation. Tim believes that the industry has created a disease where none really existed, while Federica sees the insufficiency range as an opportunity to improve health markers. Both agree that getting a blood test for 25-hydroxy D levels can give an idea of vitamin D status, but Tim also mentions the alternative test of parathyroid hormone levels in some countries. However, they both caution against over-reliance on vitamin D supplementation, as it may divert attention from other important aspects of healthcare. Tim Spector explains that if your blood test shows you have low levels of vitamin D, your doctor may prescribe a supplement. Different countries have varying cut-off levels for vitamin D deficiency, and different medical specialties may also have different recommendations. Despite numerous trials showing that vitamin D supplements may not be effective in preventing fractures or treating various conditions, it is still commonly prescribed. Observational studies have shown an association between vitamin D levels and various diseases, but clinical trials have not consistently supported these findings. Mendelian randomization studies, which examine the genetic basis of vitamin D levels, may provide further insight into the role of vitamin D in health outcomes. There are 10 gene variants that can affect our vitamin D levels, leading to higher or lower levels in different individuals. These genetic differences can result in varying vitamin D production even if people have similar diets and sun exposure. It is possible for one person to have lower vitamin D levels than another due to their genetic makeup. Research has shown that individuals with gene variants associated with low vitamin D levels do not necessarily have higher fracture rates, debunking the belief that vitamin D supplementation is crucial for bone health. In fact, there is little evidence supporting the use of vitamin D supplements for bone health once deficiency is addressed. Taking high doses of vitamin D, especially in combination with calcium, can potentially be harmful, leading to increased fracture risks and other health issues. It is advised to avoid calcium supplementation unless specifically prescribed by a doctor, as it has been linked to adverse effects, particularly on heart health. While vitamin D alone may seem harmless, it is possible to overdose on it, leading to various health problems such as nerve and muscle issues. It is important to be cautious with vitamin D supplementation and avoid self-medicating with high doses obtained from the internet. Depending on the form in which you take it, the statement that vitamin D can build up and be dangerous is generally correct. It is important to consider that taking a supplement in a chemical form differs from obtaining it through sunlight or food. For example, taking too much of a pharmaceutical form of vitamin D can pose risks, similar to how excessive consumption of a drug like paracetamol can be harmful. Unlike natural sources of vitamin D, there is no regulatory system in place to control the intake of pharmaceutical vitamin D.

While much of the discussion around vitamin D has focused on its role in bone health and fracture prevention, there is more to its potential benefits. Research suggests that vitamin D plays a role in immune system function, and supplementation may be beneficial for individuals with conditions like Crohn's disease or cancer. However, it is important to understand that not everyone may benefit from vitamin D supplementation, and excessive intake can lead to toxicity. It is recommended to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any supplementation regimen, especially for those who may have difficulty obtaining enough vitamin D through sunlight exposure. Following recommended daily intake guidelines can help avoid the risk of vitamin D toxicity. I want to emphasize that not everyone living in northern Europe or parts of northern America and Canada should rely heavily on vitamin D. Our bodies have evolved over thousands of years to adapt to the right conditions, so it's important to remember that. A diverse diet can also contribute to our overall health.

There are certain conditions, such as multiple sclerosis, that vitamin D may help prevent. Research has shown a connection between living in cold climates and an increased risk of multiple sclerosis, particularly in the northern hemisphere. In cases where there is a family history or increased risk, ensuring adequate levels of vitamin D may be beneficial.

While supplements may be necessary for some individuals, especially those living in areas with limited sunlight like Alaska or Scotland, sunlight and a balanced diet are generally better options for most people. Foods such as dairy products, oily fish, and mushrooms are good sources of vitamin D that can be incorporated into daily meals to help meet our requirements.

It's important to be mindful of our individual needs based on factors like skin color and environment. Sun exposure is a natural way to boost vitamin D levels, but it's essential to strike a balance between getting enough sunlight and reducing the risk of skin cancer. Using sunbeds as a shortcut to increase vitamin D is not recommended.

The debate around sun exposure and sunscreen is complex, especially in relation to vitamin D levels and overall health. It's crucial to consider the nuanced perspectives on this issue and make informed decisions based on individual circumstances. It was highlighted how important vitamin D is for the immune system to combat cancers. Additionally, the pervasive message of year-round sunscreen use, promoted by the sunscreen industry through charities, was questioned. Dermatologists found no rationale for constant sunscreen use, especially in regions where sunlight is limited and vitamin D production is crucial. The discussion also touched on the use of vitamin D for COVID prevention, with studies showing varying results based on individual deficiencies. The importance of assessing one's own vitamin D levels and focusing on a diverse diet and sunlight exposure was emphasized as a more sustainable approach to overall health. Instead of wasting money on supplements that have been proven ineffective, it would be more beneficial to focus on consuming a diverse diet with real foods that provide essential nutrients. This approach, along with getting sunlight exposure and engaging in outdoor activities, can have a greater impact on overall health. Remember, it's important to prioritize healthy habits rather than relying solely on supplements for health benefits. On the flip side, it's important to consider getting some vitamin D from sunlight, especially during the winter months when sunscreen may not be necessary for short periods of time. Personally, I've been granted permission by my wife to skip sunscreen during the winter months, showing a shift in views over time.

This shift in perspective is reflective of evolving medical opinions, with dermatologists and experts now emphasizing the importance of obtaining vitamin D naturally from the sun rather than relying solely on supplements. It's crucial to remain open-minded, as recommendations and beliefs in the medical field are subject to change based on new evidence.

While some may have been skeptical of vitamin D supplementation in the past, recent studies are proving the validity of this approach. It's essential to approach health decisions with caution and not be swayed by marketing tactics promoting ineffective products.

As we navigate the complexities of health and nutrition, it's important to focus on simple yet effective practices like consuming a whole-food-based diet and staying active. Embracing a holistic approach to health, which includes diversity in our lifestyle choices, can have a significant impact on overall well-being.

In conclusion, it's clear that our understanding of health and nutrition is constantly evolving, and it's crucial to stay informed and adapt our practices accordingly. By prioritizing natural sources of vitamin D and making mindful choices in our diet and lifestyle, we can work towards improving our health and well-being in the long run. To ensure the seamless integration of the original HTML content into a WordPress platform, we will first need to convert the HTML code into WordPress-friendly format. This will involve creating a new WordPress template that mirrors the structure of the original HTML page.

Next, we will need to transfer the content from the original HTML page to the new WordPress template. This will involve copying and pasting the text, images, and other elements from the HTML page into the corresponding sections of the WordPress template.

Once the content has been transferred, we will need to ensure that the original HTML tags, images, HTML header, and key points are preserved. This will involve checking that all of the formatting and styling from the original HTML page has been accurately replicated in the WordPress template.

Finally, we will need to test the new WordPress page to ensure that all of the elements are displaying correctly and that the page is fully functional. This will involve checking that all of the links are working, the images are loading correctly, and that the page is responsive on different devices.

By following these steps, we can ensure that the original HTML content is seamlessly integrated into a WordPress platform while preserving all of the key elements from the original page.